I went to my brokerage’s sales meeting last week (Knapp Realty formerly known as Keller Knapp Realty). One of the brokers invited me and said they’d be talking about the new appraisal report and might give me a shout-out. I like to be available to the agents in my brokerage, so I went.
A quick aside for anyone wondering. Yes, I hold a license with a brokerage. No, I don’t do much agent work. Over the last couple of years it’s been mostly friends and family, if anything at all, plus one referral fee. I keep that side of things well away from my appraisal work. Independence isn’t something I take lightly. That’s a whole other post, and I could digress.
Back to the meeting. They went over the new appraisal report, and the one thing that really landed with the room, the thing people nodded at and repeated to each other on the way out, was this:
The appraised value is on the front page now.
That’s the big takeaway. The number is on the front.
I’ll admit I laughed a little. I’ve been doing this since 2002. I’ve poured myself into these reports. I’ve chosen comparable sales and defended them. I’ve worked out adjustments and then supported them. I’ve studied the market to figure out whether prices are going up, going down or just sitting there. I’ve written sales comparison commentary that I was honestly a little proud of. I’ve reconciled, re-reconciled, and checked the details one more time.
And the headline from all of it is that you don’t have to flip to page six anymore.
Makes sense to me, really. It’s a good reminder of what people actually care about. Almost nobody reads an appraisal for the quality of the analysis. They read it for the number. Correct me if I’m wrong, but I’ve never had an agent call to say, “Great work on the market conditions section.”
That has an uncomfortable flip side, and it cuts both ways.
Say an appraiser fills in the form, does the least he can get away with, and turns it in. If the value comes in where everyone hoped, he’s a hero, and nobody looks any further.
Now say an appraiser does everything right. He develops the assignment properly, follows the ethics rules, supports every adjustment, and reports what the market actually says. If that number comes in short, he’s no different, in most people’s eyes, from someone who cut every corner. It’s just a “bad appraisal.”
In both cases the work behind the number is invisible. Only the number counts.
I’m not complaining. Well, maybe a little. But I think it’s worth saying, because the work behind the number is the whole point. Lenders, buyers and sellers depend on a value that’s credible, not just convenient. The number is only as good as what’s behind it, even if hardly anyone turns the page to look.
So, agents, by all means read the front page. That’s what it’s there for. But if the number surprises you, good or bad, the explanation is in the pages after it. I promise I wrote them for a reason.
And to my brokerage, thanks for the invite and the shout-out. Glad to be in the room.
Questions about serving your clients during the UAD 3.6 transition? I am always happy to talk. Call me at 404-245-7577.
Cameron Horne, GACR253993 Comp One Appraisal Services, Inc.
Questions about how to better serve your client in light of the coming UAD 3.6 transition? I'm always happy to talk. Call anytime at 404-245-7577